Comparing 2001 cynicism towards internet with 2014 cynicism towards cleantech


Remember the pub bores of circa 2001 who were adamant that the internet was a flash in the pan? At the time, with share prices of many internet pioneers in free fall, they may have seemed right. They weren’t. Facebook, Amazon, Linkedin and one or two others have done rather well in the intervening years.

The same is true of the clean technology sector today. Headline failures of ‘new energy’ companies typically undermined by cheap shale gas and Chinese silicon are obscuring the view of both current and future success, particularly outside the energy sector. In a decade or less we will laugh at the pub bore 2014 vintage who damned clean technology as a failed venture. It’s only just begun!

A good example is biopesticides, where the essential ingredients of successful clean technology venturing are all in place: innovation, acquisition-hungry corporates, strong regulations, seasoned clean technology VCs with corporate backers and/or corporate venturing backgrounds.

“Biopesticides are a great example of non-energy cleantech succeeding,” says Keith Gillard, General Partner at Pangaea Ventures, the Vancouver-based VC focused on advanced materials. Pangaea’s roster of corporate LPs includes Evonik, BASF and Mitsubishi Chemical. “Clean energy may have claimed most of the cleantech dollars, but the non-energy side of cleantech is still going strong,” he says.

Gillard, who previously worked in venturing at BASF, has two biopesticide companies in his portfolio; Vestaron and New Leaf. Vestaron’s biopesticides are derived from spider venom. New Leaf’s are derived from naturally occurring bacteria called Pink Pigmented Facultative Methylotrophs (PPFMs). Both companies aim to displace conventional ‘dirty’ pesticides from the fruit and vegetable industry. If they succeed, that’ll be cleantech lettuce in your pub sandwich quite soon.
In 2011, the EU’s Plant Protection Products Regulation made 74% of all commercial pesticides illegal. This helped open the door to a flurry of ‘landgrab’ biopesticide deals.
In January 2013 Monsanto paid over $100m for the bio library of Agradis, a company which had been created only a year and half earlier. This followed five other deals in 2012 and 2011: Bayer bought AgraQuest for $500m and Athenix for $420m. Syngenta bought Pasteuria for $100m. BASF bought Becker Underwood for $1bn. Monsanto bought Divergence for $75m and Beeologics for $125m. Some of the investors in the acquired companies enjoyed the ‘10x grand slam’ return that is the benchmark of successful venturing.

Biopesticides are hot because they fit the proven formula for successful clean technology venturing:

(Innovation + regulatory change) x corporate appetite = a damn good clean technology investment

Not surprisingly, Pangaea’s Gillard reports growing corporate interest in biopesticides and in other agtech sectors. In addition to the big six; BASF, Bayer, Dow, Dupont (Pioneer), Monsanto and Syngenta), he reports interest from newcomers.

“We are also seeing engagement from Limagrain, Valent, Novozymes, FMC, Scott’s Miracle Gro, and others … in addition, I have been fielding inquiries from chemical companies who have not previously offered much in the way of bio- or ag-products; they are seeing the way the market is developing and looking to see if there is an opportunity for them in this rapidly changing but enormous market.”

There’s a simple moral in the growing biopesticides story. Clean technology can succeed when it is significantly superior to incumbent technologies whose days are numbered because of regulatory change (change which is driven by consumer and NGO pressure for superior environmental standards).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s